Balthazar's Suffering, Reelive

Girl
Girl

Why don't you come and play with us, Balthazar?

Man
Man

Leave him be! He's a donkey.

Girl
Girl

But he can understand us!

Man
Man

Animals can't understand anything.

Girl
Girl

I think he feels what we feel.

Man
Man

Don't be silly. He's just a beast.

Girl
Girl

No, he's more than that. He's special.

Man
Man

Enough talking. Let's move on.

The Return, Reelive

Marie
Marie

Balthazar, you came back!

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

I knew you would! It's been so lonely.

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

I missed you. Did they treat you well?

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

I promise I will take care of you now.

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Life's Cruelty, Reelive

Young Man
Young Man

Life is cruel, isn't it?

Old Man
Old Man

What do you expect? It always has been.

Young Man
Young Man

You think it ever gets better?

Old Man
Old Man

Sometimes, but mostly it just hurts.

Young Man
Young Man

Even for animals? Even for Balthazar?

Old Man
Old Man

Especially for them. They feel more than we do.

Young Man
Young Man

That’s what makes it harder to watch.

Old Man
Old Man

Pain is universal.

Choosing the Path, Reelive

Marie
Marie

I can’t leave you, Balthazar.

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

If I go, who will care for you?

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

I have to think about us.

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie
Marie

What if it’s the only way?

Balthazar
Balthazar

...

Marie

Balthazar, you are the only one who has ever loved me.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Priest

It's not how you die; it's how you live.

The Priest

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Old Man

Animal and man, we are all part of this life. Suffering unites us.

The Old Man

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

Balthazar, for you, there are no miracles left.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Farmer

Life is not always what we want it to be.

The Farmer

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Narrator

He is more than just a donkey; he is a witness to our sorrows.

Narrator

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Priest

To suffer is to live; who doesn't suffer, doesn't exist.

The Priest

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Teacher

When we look at the animal, we should see ourselves.

The Teacher

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

What can we do, except bear our wounds?

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Young Boy

Balthazar knows more than we do.

The Young Boy

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Merchant

In this world, we deceive ourselves as much as we deceive others.

The Merchant

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

Love does not always bring happiness.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Priest

The weight of the world is heavy for the innocent.

The Priest

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Father

Happiness is fleeting, like a shadow.

The Father

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

Sometimes, kindness is our only salvation.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Farmer

We are made to suffer, it's part of the game.

The Farmer

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

Balthazar, you carry the burdens we can't express.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Old Man

In the presence of pain, we find our truth.

The Old Man

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Priest

Every life has its struggles; we must find meaning in them.

The Priest

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
Marie

Forgive, but never forget.

Marie

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive
The Merchant

We fight our wars, but what do we gain?

The Merchant

Au Hasard Balthazar, Reelive

Balthazar's First Encounter with Marie

In the quiet rural setting, we see a young Marie eagerly playing with Balthazar, the donkey. Their bond is pure and innocent, showing a deep connection between human and animal. This moment is crucial as it establishes Marie's character and her gentle spirit, contrasting the harsh world that follows. Their playful interaction, punctuated by soft music, creates a tranquil atmosphere that highlights the beauty of their friendship.

Context: Marie is introduced as a sweet and innocent child, and her relationship with Balthazar sets the emotional tone for the film.

Balthazar's Loneliness

As Balthazar is passed from owner to owner, the camera lingers on his expressive eyes. The sadness is palpable as we watch him endure neglect and mistreatment. The pivotal moment is when he’s tied up and left alone in a dark shed, symbolizing the theme of suffering. Viewers feel the weight of his loneliness and the cruelty of the human world around him.

Context: Balthazar serves as a mirror to the human condition, experiencing suffering that reflects Marie's own struggles in life.

Marie’s Transformation

Marie grows up into a troubled young woman, and her reunion with Balthazar is bittersweet. Their eyes meet, filled with recognition and longing. The dialogue that transpires is minimal but powerful, loaded with unspoken emotions. This encounter marks a turning point as both characters have suffered deeply, yet the bond transcends their struggles.

Context: Years have passed, and this reunion represents both a personal escape for Marie and a deepening of Balthazar’s purpose.

The Cruelty of the School

In a stark schoolroom, Marie faces bullying from her peers. The harshness of their words cuts deep, capturing her isolation. The pivotal moment occurs when she stands up, asserting her dignity in front of the class, showcasing her growth. The tension and sympathy felt by the audience create a powerful emotional impact.

Context: This scene emphasizes themes of isolation and resilience, providing insight into Marie's struggles.

Balthazar's Sacrifice

In a shocking turn, Balthazar is forced to carry a heavy load despite his frail condition. The camera focuses on his weary legs as he struggles under the weight. It’s a moment that elevates the theme of sacrifice, as Balthazar endures pain to help others. The audience feels a mix of despair and admiration, highlighting the film's moral compass.

Context: This moment showcases Balthazar's loyalty and selflessness, reinforcing the deep bond between him and Marie.

The Death of Balthazar

In a heart-wrenching climax, Balthazar's demise unfolds slowly. The atmosphere is heavy, filled with the sounds of mourning. As he lies on the ground, Marie rushes to his side. Their last moments together evoke profound sadness. The scene is marked by silence, allowing viewers to soak in the weight of loss, a culmination of love and suffering.

Context: Balthazar's death symbolizes the end of an era and the tragedy that winds through the lives of both him and Marie.

Marie’s Despair

After Balthazar's death, Marie finds herself in a locked room, her anguish palpable. The camera shows her crumpled on the floor, tears streaming down her face. This emotional outburst unveils the raw pain she feels from the loss. The silence accentuates her heartache, making viewers feel her sorrow deeply.

Context: This moment encapsulates the crushing weight of grief and the irreversible impact of losing a loved one.

The Festival Scene

At a local festival, there’s a juxtaposition of joy and Balthazar's absence. Marie engages in playful activities, but her eyes betray her inner turmoil. This moment reflects the struggle between the need for happiness and the shadow of grief. The colorful visuals contrast sharply with her emotional state, creating tension.

Context: The festival serves as a reminder of lost joy due to the circumstances surrounding both Marie and Balthazar.

The Last Meeting

In an emotional climax, Marie approaches Balthazar one last time in a symbolic scene of closure. She recalls their shared moments. The montage of memories plays as she speaks gently to him, culminating in a heartwarming yet heart-wrenching farewell. This moment represents love transcending life.

Context: This scene captures the essence of their bond, suggesting that love remains even in loss.

Marie’s Reflective Journey

During a silent walk in nature post-Balthazar, Marie reflects on her life. The camera captures her contemplative expressions as she walks barefoot on the grass. The sound of nature surrounds her, fading into an emotional epiphany about life and loss. Viewers feel a sense of tranquility amidst the sadness.

Context: This moment symbolizes healing and the importance of remembering loved ones in the cycle of life.

The Unseen Connections

As Balthazar observes various characters interact around him, the film highlights their human flaws and struggles. The camera pans over them as they argue and reconcile. The pivotal moment is when viewers realize how deeply intertwined their lives are with Balthazar's. This moment emphasizes the film's critique of human nature.

Context: This scene underscores how Balthazar is a witness to the complexities of human life, highlighting the trial of existence.

The Power of Silence

An extended silence envelops a scene where Marie watches children play. The absence of dialogue showcases her isolation. The quietness speaks volumes, mirroring her feelings of detachment. This moment is significant as it encapsulates her struggle to fit into the world around her.

Context: The silence serves as a powerful narrative device that intensifies the film's emotional depth and theme of alienation.

The Symbol of the Cross

Towards the film's end, Balthazar’s form is seen against a backdrop of a cross, a visual metaphor for suffering and redemption. This moment resonates deeply with viewers, as it connects Balthazar’s journey with broader themes of faith and sacrifice. The image is striking and leaves a lasting impression.

Context: This moment cements the film's exploration of profound themes involving suffering and spiritual rebirth.

Marie’s Resolve

In a quiet moment of determination, Marie decides to take control of her life. The camera captures her stepping forward into a new chapter, away from her painful past. This revelation is subtle yet powerful, depicting her growth. Viewers feel a surge of hope amidst the sadness.

Context: This moment highlights Marie’s evolution, reinforcing the theme of resilience in the face of hardship.

The Moment of Recognition

A brief yet profound interaction between a stranger and Marie sparks recognition of shared pain. Their eyes lock, and for a moment, an unspoken understanding is exchanged. This moment encapsulates human connection amidst suffering, resonating with viewers on a relatable level.

Context: This scene emphasizes the film's theme of empathy towards others experiencing similar struggles.

Nature’s Healing

In a serene landscape, Marie allows herself to feel free, running across fields under the sun. The joy amid nature contrasts sharply with her previous trauma. This moment signifies healing and returning to innocence, brightening the film's tone temporarily.

Context: This brief escape reflects the natural world's ability to bring solace even in pain.

Balthazar's Eyes

In a poignant scene, the camera focuses on Balthazar's eyes as he endures pain and hardship. His expressive gaze communicates a wealth of emotion, connecting viewers emotionally to his plight. This moment showcases the film's artistry in portraying non-verbal storytelling.

Context: Balthazar's eyes become a window into the emotional core of the film, provoking empathy from the audience.

Marie and Innocence Lost

After facing betrayal, Marie stands in the rain, symbolizing her lost innocence. The rain pours down, mirroring her tears as she grapples with profound emotional upheaval. The visual storytelling is impactful, evoking feelings of sympathy and despair.

Context: This scene serves as a turning point in Marie's character development, highlighting her loss of purity and hope.

The Passing of Time

A montage unfolds, showcasing the seasons changing as Balthazar and Marie navigate their lives. This visual element serves to emphasize the passage of time and its relentless nature. Moments of joy and sorrow are intertwined, creating a bittersweet tone that resonates with viewers.

Context: The passage of time highlights the inevitability of change, encapsulating life's fleeting nature intertwined with love and loss.

The Moment of Clarity

In a moment of quiet contemplation, Marie gazes at the sky, as if asking questions about life and purpose. This reflective stance invites the audience to share her introspection, allowing them to engage deeply with her character. The silence here is piercing, amplifying the weight of her thoughts.

Context: This moment encapsulates the film's exploration of existential themes, inviting viewers to ponder their own lives.


Download App

The Use of Non-Professional Actors

Director Robert Bresson primarily trained non-professional actors for 'Au Hasard Balthazar,' which was a significant departure from traditional casting methods.

Why it matters: This choice added a layer of authenticity to the characters and enabled a raw emotional portrayal that resonated deeply with audiences, enhancing the film's exploration of suffering and innocence.

Balthazar's Role

The donkey, Balthazar, was not just a prop but was given a significant role in the storytelling, embodying a silent witness to the human suffering around him.

Why it matters: Bresson’s decision to elevate Balthazar's presence in the story created a unique perspective, allowing viewers to project their interpretations onto the donkey and deepening the film's thematic complexity.

Symbolism of the Donkey

The donkey's journey throughout the film serves as a metaphor for the human condition, reflecting societal injustices and personal traumas.

Why it matters: This symbolic choice instills a philosophical depth to the narrative, inviting audiences to reflect on the relationship between humanity and the animal world.

Shooting in Natural Light

Bresson opted to shoot 'Au Hasard Balthazar' mostly in natural light, avoiding artificial lighting setups.

Why it matters: This technique contributed to a more intimate and authentic atmosphere, making the emotional weight of the scenes feel more immediate and impactful.

Sound Design Choices

Bresson incorporated the sounds of nature and everyday life, contrasting them with the often chaotic and distressing moments of the characters’ lives.

Why it matters: This sound design emphasizes the stark realities the characters face, allowing audiences to experience an emotional juxtaposition that enhances the film's pessimistic themes.

The Framing of Shots

Bresson meticulously framed every shot to create a sense of composition that reflects the characters' psychological states.

Why it matters: This visual storytelling technique guided the audience's emotional responses, as the carefully composed shots often mirror the despair and beauty in human life.

Influences from Bresson's Previous Work

The film draws influences from Bresson's earlier works, particularly in its philosophical exploration and minimalist style.

Why it matters: This connection not only showcases Bresson's evolving vision as a filmmaker but also enriches the viewing experience for those familiar with his oeuvre.

Crew's Unique Approach

Bresson’s crew employed a unique shooting schedule, emphasizing spontaneity and immediate responses to the actors' performances.

Why it matters: This unconventional approach allowed for genuine emotional moments to occur, making the interactions between characters feel more authentic and raw.

Scarcity of Dialogue

The film features a sparse amount of dialogue, with many scenes relying on visual storytelling rather than spoken words.

Why it matters: This minimalist approach forces the audience to engage more deeply with the visuals and emotions, creating a more profound cinematic experience.

Cinematography Techniques

The film’s cinematographer, Léonce-Henri Burel, used a handheld camera to capture the raw and intimate moments between characters and Balthazar.

Why it matters: This technique creates a sense of immediacy and connection, allowing audiences to feel as if they are part of the narrative, heightening emotional engagement.

The Initial Concept

Bresson initially conceived the film as a straightforward narrative but later transformed it into a more allegorical tale.

Why it matters: This shift resulted in a film rich with thematic layers, encouraging viewers to reflect on broader existential questions.

Balthazar's Training

The donkey Balthazar underwent specific training to perform different actions on cue, but Bresson also embraced moments of spontaneity.

Why it matters: This blend of trained and natural behavior in Balthazar highlights the unpredictability of life and adds to the film’s authenticity.

Inspiration from Literature

The film is inspired by the short story 'Balthazar' by the French writer, which Bresson adapted for the screen.

Why it matters: This literary connection showcases Bresson’s ability to transform written narratives into compelling visual art, bridging the gap between literature and cinema.

The Use of Cues

Actors were often given minimal cues during filming, relying on their instincts to guide their performances.

Why it matters: This technique fostered a naturalistic portrayal of emotions, allowing for unpredictable and genuine interactions that resonate deeply with viewers.

Balthazar's Departure

The climactic moment involving Balthazar's departure was filmed with limited takes to capture the raw emotion of loss.

Why it matters: This decision intensified the emotional weight of the scene, making it one of the film's most memorable and moving points.

Cultural Reception

Upon its release, 'Au Hasard Balthazar' was met with a mix of admiration and confusion, with audiences polarized by its style and themes.

Why it matters: This reaction contributed to the film's legacy as a polarizing but significant work, prompting discussions about the role of cinema in exploring deeper philosophical themes.

The Role of Silence

Silence plays a crucial role in the film, often used strategically to underscore emotional moments.

Why it matters: The use of silence allows audiences to absorb critical scenes, heightening emotional reactions and creating a lasting impact.


Download App

The Social Media App for Movie & TV Enthusiasts
👉 Reelive App 👈

No mods, no censorship—just a space to relive epic movie moments. Like Reddit, but made for movie lovers.

Download App

La Notte

French Fried Vacation 2

The Deer Hunter